Prospeo vs LeadMagic: which should you choose in 2026

Side-by-Side Comparison

Prospeo and LeadMagic both pull verified emails from LinkedIn profiles, but they're designed for different buyers. Prospeo wins on flat-rate credit pricing and Sales Navigator depth. LeadMagic wins on mobile number coverage and API flexibility. The decision comes down to whether you need cell data alongside emails.

What Prospeo Gets Right

Prospeo is the cleaner pick for LinkedIn-heavy teams on a predictable budget. Its Chrome extension pulls verified emails from Sales Navigator profiles in one click, with verification built into the credit cost rather than billed separately. The Business plan's 20,000 credits for $199/mo is hard to beat on pure email volume.

One credit finds and verifies an email, per Prospeo's documentation. Most competitors split finding and verification into two separate charges, which inflates the real cost per contact by 30 to 50 percent. On 5,000 contacts a month, that's a meaningful budget difference.

The Sales Navigator integration is the real differentiator. Most email finders struggle with Sales Nav profile URLs. Prospeo handles bulk exports from Sales Nav searches reliably. The limits: no mobile numbers, thin API access for technical teams, and the free tier (75 credits/mo) runs out in an afternoon of serious prospecting.

What LeadMagic Gets Right

LeadMagic is the better pick when cold calling is part of your outbound motion. Its mobile number finder surfaces verified cell data alongside professional emails, making it the only tool in this comparison built for true multichannel outreach, per LeadMagic's product page.

The pay-as-you-go model works for teams with swinging monthly volume. You don't pay for unused credits after a slow month. For teams consistently finding 3,000+ contacts monthly, though, flat subscription pricing beats per-credit billing on unit cost every time.

The API is built for technical buyers running Clay workflows or custom enrichment pipelines. You can push data into a CRM without a CSV export step. The tradeoff: bills spike without a ceiling when prospecting volume ramps fast.

Pricing: What You Actually Pay

Prospeo's subscriptions beat LeadMagic's pay-as-you-go rates above 500 contacts per month. At 5,000 credits, Prospeo charges $99/mo flat, per Prospeo's pricing page. LeadMagic at similar email volume runs higher on on-demand rates, per LeadMagic's pricing page, unless you've negotiated a volume deal directly.

Which Tool Should You Choose?

Prospeo is the right call for most teams doing LinkedIn-first prospecting under 20,000 contacts monthly. LeadMagic makes sense only when mobile numbers or API flexibility are non-negotiable requirements for your workflow.

Choose Prospeo if you use LinkedIn or Sales Navigator daily, want flat predictable billing, and need a clean browser-extension workflow without API configuration. It's the better fit for two-to-five person SDR teams and founders doing their own outreach.

Choose LeadMagic if mobile phone numbers are core to your connect strategy, you run Clay pipelines or custom enrichment stacks, or your monthly volume swings enough that pay-as-you-go wins on cost. If you'd rather not build and manage this prospecting stack yourself, that's what Modern Inbound handles.

Want Research-Led Outreach Run For You?

Modern Inbound mines buyer language, builds account lists, writes outreach, manages client-owned inboxes, and routes qualified replies. Your team gets sales conversations, not another tool to operate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Prospeo better than LeadMagic for LinkedIn prospecting?

Yes, for most teams. Prospeo's Chrome extension and Sales Navigator integration make it more practical for LinkedIn-native workflows. LeadMagic's API-first design suits technical teams building enrichment pipelines, not day-to-day LinkedIn prospecting.

Does LeadMagic find mobile phone numbers?

Yes. LeadMagic includes a dedicated mobile and cell number finder, per LeadMagic's product page. Prospeo focuses on professional email addresses and doesn't offer a comparable mobile data product.

Which tool is cheaper at high volume?

Prospeo is cheaper at volume. Its Business plan at $199/mo covers 20,000 credits, per Prospeo's pricing page. LeadMagic's pay-as-you-go rates cost more per find at that scale without a negotiated volume deal.

Does Prospeo work with Sales Navigator?

Yes. Prospeo's Chrome extension works on Sales Navigator profile pages and supports bulk exports from Sales Nav search results. It's one of the few email finders with reliable Sales Navigator support, per Prospeo's feature documentation.